Must-Try Halloween Pumpkin Punch Game: Will it Be Trick or Treat?
This Halloween Pumpkin Cup Punch Game is a simple, silly game where every cup hides a surprise. And nobody knows what they’ll get until they punch through!
It’s easy to set up, fun for kids and adults, and guaranteed to bring plenty of laughs to your Halloween party.
This game can be used as a standalone party game, trick or treating, or as a prize for other games.
This article contains affiliate links at no cost to you. See my disclaimer for more.
Would you like to save this idea?
Enter your email and I'll send the link straight to you.
Contents
Supplies You Need For This Punch Board Game
All you need to play is:
- Foam board
- Glue gun and glue sticks
- Solo cups
- Prizes (I like to do a mix of gift cards, money, candy, and other small things). This time, I threw in small toy trains and small Play Doh containers. Gag gifts can be funny too to make some “tricks.”
- Orange and black tissue paper (you could also add brown for a stem)
- Scissors
- Rubber bands
Note: To make sure everyone gets a turn, you’ll want to have as many (or more) cups than people at your gathering. Make a few backup cups if you aren’t sure.
To Set Up The Pumpkin Punch Cup Game
Before you can play, you’ll have to make the punch board.
1. First, lay out your cups on the foam board to figure out your design and the number of cups you need. The picture below is of a Valentine’s Day Heart punch game. For this one, all you need is a circle.
Again, you’ll want to use enough cups for everyone at the party, so if you’re doing a classroom party, make sure you have enough cups for the whole class. (Read to the end for tips if your group is too big for your board). You can also keep all of your prizes the same to make it equal.
2. Once you’ve figured out your design, fill all of your cups with gift cards, money, candy, or gag gifts (more ideas at the end!). Make sure you keep it random, and no one sees where you put them.
3. Next, you need to cover your cups so that players have something to punch through. I cut my sheets of tissue paper in half, but it will depend on how big your tissue paper is in the package. (Cut them all at once to make it faster!)
Your tissue paper squares don’t need to be perfect or huge. They just need to be able to cover the cups.
4. Place the piece of tissue paper on top of your cup.
Then, wrap a rubber band around the tissue paper and cup to secure the paper to the cup.
Repeat this process with all of your tissue paper until all of your cups are covered.
5. Finally, hot glue the bottom of each cup to its spot and place them hot glue side down on the board. Keep going until they’re all glued down, looking like the design you want.
Pro Tip: I’ve used this foam board multiple times. It’s easy to reuse the cups, rubber bands, and board for other punch cup games, like this Rudolph one.
Objective of the Jack O’Lantern Punch Game
The objective is to “punch” a cup with a fun prize in it! This is just a silly and exciting way to give away fun stuff at Halloween 🙂
What Makes This Game So Fun?
It’s the suspense and mystery of not knowing what’s in each cup. Plus, it’s surprisingly satisfying to punch your way through something! (If you don’t know what I’m talking about, you definitely need to play this game!)
Fun fact: The punch game is inspired by The Price Is Right, where contestants punched through paper circles to reveal hidden prizes.
Now it’s time to get playing. Keep reading to find out how!
Fun Prize Ideas for This Heart Game Board
While everyone loves the basics (money, gift cards, and candy), this themed punch game is even more fun when you get creative. Try some of these too:
- Tokens to bigger prizes like lotion, candles, or toys.
- Stickers or temporary tattoos
- Coupons for things like “no chores for a day”
- Glow sticks
- Halloween jokes and riddles
- Chocolate upgrade ticket – redeem it for a full-size chocolate bar
Related: Fun Trick or Treat Ideas That Aren’t Candy
How to Play The Jack O’Lantern Punch Game
The general idea of a punch game is simple. Everyone gets a turn, and on their turn, they choose one cup to punch through (unless you’ve made enough for multiples)
They pull out any prizes inside and keep them.
This is also a great candy alternative for trick or treaters! Last year, we had neighbors give kids the option of candy from a bowl or a punch for a non-candy prize.
Fun Punch Cup Board Game Variations
For a fun variation, you can pair it with another game on the site and make it more of a prize game when they win.
- Have participants answer Halloween trivia questions to be able to punch.
- Play these Halloween Minute to Win It games and let the winners punch a cup.
- Play Halloween bingo
- Play Halloween Themed Forbidden Words
- Play The Halloween Categories Game
- Play Halloween Friendly Feud
Check out all the Halloween games for more ways you can use this pumpkin punch cup game as a prize picker!
You can also turn this punch game into a fun October countdown. Write down your favorite Halloween activities on slips of paper. Then, put them in the cups before you add the tissue paper. For every day in October, have your kids punch one cup to see what you do for the day!
Common Questions and Answers
What if the players don’t like their prizes?
You get to make the rules for this game! If they don’t like their prize and want to switch with someone else who doesn’t like their prize, they can. Or you can decide beforehand that all players keep what they get.
What if you have more people than you have space on the board?
If you have more players than space on your foam board, prepare extra pre-filled cups ahead of time and keep them off to the side. As players punch out cups, replace the empty ones with the ready-to-go cups. It’s a perfect solution for large groups!
What else could you do for a Halloween punch solo cup game board?
Try a ghost, monster, or witch hat. Or stick with a pumpkin (it’s the easiest). Whatever you do, your guests are going to LOVE the suspense and mystery that this game brings!
Halloween Games Pack
Snag holiday favorites like Family Feud, The 5-second Game, and more in the Halloween Games Pack.
What’s Next?
Join tens of thousands and sign up for the Family Table Newsletter. You’ll get the best family content and free resources right to your inbox.